The Caples Awards 2021

Gavin McLeod from Australia, Sebastien de Valck from Belgium, Dave Federico from Canada, Pancho Gonzalez from Chile, Myriam Fynecontry-Herke and Karl-Wolfgang Epple from Germany, Meera Sharath Chandra from India, Jen Speirs, from Ireland, Iska Hashim and Nina Mohammed-Nor from Malaysia, Kim Pick from New Zealand, Nuno Duarte from Portugal, Beto Nahmad from Spain.

From the UAE, Ali Rez and Paul Banham.

From the UK, Adam Bodfish, Becky McOwen-Banks, Ben Polkinghorne, Charlie Wilson, Cordell Burke, Duncan Gray , Elspeth Lynn , Nicky Bullard, Trevor Chambers and Vikki Ross.

From the USA, Ben Kay, Jenna Young, Jill Applebaum, Jonathan Butts, Katie Keating, Mike Tunney and Ron Copeland.

President of the 2021 Caples Awards jury, Steve Aldridge

Responsibility

President of the jury Steve Aldridge, Chief Creative Officer of Wunderman Thompson London, briefed the jury:

"This is an exciting time to be a judge at the Caples. The show is turbo-charging itself.

In being free to enter, there is a democratisation of creativity. The strength of the idea is all.

My personal spin is I like big ideas, ideas that have some longevity. There's a tendency to look for stunts and one-offs. That said, do not disregard the little jewel of an idea. Not everything needs to be a massive campaign with video at the centre of it all.

I'd also urge you to think about the day-to-day challenges you all have with your clients so look to reward real-world solutions to real-world business problems.

I also think the sponsorship of The Caples Awards this year by BBDO and WPP is a step-change.

It says loud and clear that these two organisations value the best talent.

I think that puts a responsibility on us to make sure the work that wins is work of world-class quality. It's work we'll want to share with our teams to inspire and motivate them.

After you've judged the work, when we come together what we want is discussion and debate. We don't want good stuff to get lost nor do we want to give awards to work that will pass like a ship in the night."

Big and small

One of the characteristics of Caples' juries is how pleasant the discussions are. No bitching and back-stabbing. Most jurors managed to get together at 9am UK-time except for the folks in the Americas, where it was still the middle of the night. So there was a second review every day with them at 4pm.

The big ideas came through strongly from the start.

"Donation Dollar" from Saatchi Australia was the highest-scoring piece of work in the competition. And if you're wondering why it didn't get Best in Show then, it's because The Caples rules prohibit not-for-profit work from winning it.

Best in Show went to Wunderman Thompson Thailand for "Stay at Home Air Miles" (page 8) not because it won more Golds than any other piece of work, four in all, but because the jury agreed unanimously that it deserved it.

Firstly, because it is brave and optimistic. While most other airlines were silently facing the threat to their business from Covid, Thai Air was spending money on giveaways.

Secondly, it has real commercial purpose. Thai Air are incentivising people who might not be regular flyers to start saving in order to fly in the future. The jury liked that the success of this idea isn't measurable until late 2022 and that Thai Air are investing in the long term.

Thirdly, this is the national airline making a public statement that it cares for the people of the country.

As one of the jury said, "It's the sort of campaign that would make you proud to be a Thai."

By contrast, there was a 'small' idea that won two Golds and which set out to make Irish people ashamed of being Irish.

O.N.E's 'Sleeping Flags' from Rothco Dublin. Created to raise awareness of the plight of homeless veterans, a handful of sleeping bags pricked the conscience of a nation.

Free

At a time when jobs are under threat, many agencies are choosing to look after their people rather than spend money on awards.

Nevertheless awards remain important.

They allow creative people to benchmark themselves.

They help agencies attract talent.

And clients do pay attention to them.

Run by creative people for creative people, The Caples' primary purpose is to recognise and reward work that works.

In being the world's first major free-to-enter show, The Caples offers a new business model, one which levels the playing field, allowing small agencies to compete on equal terms with large companies.

Independent agencies who prospered at The Caples this year include

• Thinkerbell Australia, with Gold, Silver and Bronze for Bega Foods' 'The Purple Hive Project';
• VaynerMedia New York with two Golds for 'Future Official Sponsor' for Budweiser and two Bronzes for 'The Death of Mr. Peanut' for KraftHeinz.
• mortierbrigade Brussels with one Silver and two bronzes for Mooimakers 'Clean your Streetview'.
• Stendahls Stockholm with Silver for its work for the Gothenburg Film festival;
• No Fixed Address of Toronto with two Silvers and a Bronze for CCCP "Happy Birthday, Twitter";
• Zulu Alpha Kilo, also of Toronto, with Bronze for HomeEquity Bank.

Agency rankings

1	Wunderman Thompson Thailand	28
2	McCann London	20
3=	FP7 McCann MENA Happiness (FCB) Belgium	18
5	MullenLowe MENA	17
6=	Colenso BBDO New Zealand AMV BBDO London
8	BETC Brazil	15
9	Ogilvy Australia	14
10=	BBH Singapore Wunderman Thompson Dubai	13
12=	Memac Ogilvy Dubai Wunderman Thompson London	12
14	Almap BBDO Sao Paulo	11
15=	Cheil Madrid TBWA New Zealand Rothco Dublin	10