The King is a Copycat (too) - Part 1
Mark Earls
Issue 32 | September 2014
Directory is delighted to be able to publish one chapter of "Hacker, Maker, Teacher, Thief, Advertising's Next Generation", the third book from Creative Social and available from Amazon from mid-September.
Part 1
"There have been a lotta tough guys. There have been pretenders. And there have been contenders. But there is only one king." Bruce Springsteen
"He was a unique artist - an original in an area of imitators." Mick Jagger
Of all the icons of musical creativity in the 20th Century, Elvis Presley remains an original: from his early Rockabilly days with Sam Phillips' Sun Records, through his Hollywood period, to his gloriously overblown Vegas years, Elvis remains distinctly original and not just as a white man playing the blues (there were a number of those around Young Elvis' Memphis). The great classical composer and conductor, Leonard Bernstein was unstinting in his estimation of Elvis' impact, in his view:
"Elvis is the greatest cultural force in the twentieth century. He introduced the beat to everything - music, language, clothes - it's a whole new revolution. The '60s comes from it."
He changed the course of popular music with his musical choices and his vocal stylings – the Reverend Al Green, one of the greatest soul and R&B writers and performers of all time, suggests that:
"Elvis had an influence on everybody with his musical approach. He broke the ice for all of us."
And as both James Brown and Jackie Wilson noted, his act became the template for many black artists whose music he loved:
"A lot of people have accused Elvis of stealing the black man's music, when in fact, almost every black solo entertainer copied his stage mannerisms from Elvis."
Rod Stewart sees a more direct influence:
"People like myself, Mick Jagger and all the others only followed in his footsteps."
The one and only
Elvis' physical appearance – be it as the beautiful Sun-era hoodlum, the mid-era cheesecake (Warhol rightly picked out Gunslinging Elvis to play with) or the bloated jump-suited beast of the latter years – still seems so unique. Most of us have at some time tried out an Elvis move and vocal mannerism (an "uh-huh" or a "vair march") and most of the time our efforts are rewarded with recognition.
Impersonating ("paying homage") to the King is no new phenomenon – France still just about has it's own Elvis (Johnny Halliday) and Britain has both Cliff Richard, whose early career was built on Elvis impersonation, and a host of others (including Cardiff's own Michael Barrat aka Shakin' Stevens who styled himself on Truck Driver Elvis, wobbly leg and everything). You don't have to look far to see Elvis in today's leading performers – Alex Turner, frontman of the Arctic Monkeys, has recently (like so many before him) restyled himself as a young Elvis-a-like.Even today some 37 years after his death, Elvis remains one of the favourite fancy-dress choices around the world and the basis of many a night-club act. At various times and in various places, I've seen Chinese, Sikh, Jamaican, Bangladeshi and Thai Elvis impersonators. Recently the "Elvies" (an annual festival of Elvis impersonation held in the South Wales holiday resort of Porthcawl) managed to break the world record for the simultaneous performance of 942 Elvises (singing "Hound Dog" of course).
Copycat Elvis
You'd think then, that for Elvis to be "The King", to be "The Original", "The One and Only" he'd need to be, and do, original and different at every turn.
Interestingly, the truth is otherwise: Elvis wasn't even his mother's only son – he was one of a pair of identical twin boys to be delivered to Gladys Presley on January 8th 1935. Sadly Jesse Garon Presley was born stillborn and Elvis remained an only child for the rest of his life.
His music was far from original – the early swampy mix of blues, country and gospel emerged from the stew of all those gamblers, hustlers and musicians drawn from across the Mississippi delta to downtown Memphis. Indeed, the story goes that on his first session at Sun Records, it was only by accident that the hard-paced rockabilly sound was spotted. Elvis, Scotty Moore & drummer Bill Black were mucking around while a tape was being changed, racing through a fast cover version of the old country tune, "Blue Moon of Kentucky". "That's it", came a voice from the control room "that's the sound!" Over the years, his love of gospel styles (learned especially from family visits to the Tupelo Assembly of God Church) became more and more clear and visible, as did his love of sentimental ballads of all sorts.
While in later years, his management twisted the arms of songwriters to hand over a share of publishing credits to the Big Man for him doing the favour of recording their tracks (including, unsuccessfully the stony-hearted Dolly Parton) Elvis was essentially a covers artist – using other people's music as the basis of his art. For example, while you may think "Hound Dog" as a Presley tune, it was written 4 years before Elvis' cover by 19-year-old songwriters Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller and was a hit for blues singer Willie Mae "Big Mama" Thornton in 1953, spawned a handful of country-style covers and a bizarre selection of "response" and spoof records (including "Bearcat" with re-written lyrics by Sun's own Sam Phillips).
It appears that Elvis was particularly taken by the tempo and the verve of the version played and recorded by Vegas lounge act Freddie Bell & the Bellboys: "When we heard them perform that night, we thought the song would be a good one for us to do as comic relief when we were on stage. We loved the way they did it." noted guitarist Scotty Moore. So Elvis and the boys copied it and made it their own.
His clothes were not especially original or novel either: from his earliest days hanging around in Memphis, Elvis' loved the street fashion he saw from the cosmopolitan, and somewhat shady crowd that gathered on Beale Street. Local shopkeeper and tailor Bernard Lansky dressed Elvis throughout his career – as he got more famous, Lansky and his brother either closed the original Beale Street shop so that Elvis could shop unmolested by his fans, or took armfuls of "real sharp" threads up to Graceland for the King to select his own. Lansky's influence on Elvis lasted nearly 25 years: "I put his first suit on him and his last suit on him," he boasted. Over that time, Lansky introduced him to the latest street-sharp looks in Downtown Memphis. From the peg-leg pants and boxy jackets of the early days through the leather jumpsuit of the '68 comeback TV special and the white all-in-ones of the Vegas and Hawaii era – all of these looks Lansky borrowed from what hustlers and gangsters were wearing in that one small Southern city. And helped Elvis to do the same, too.
It's not even that his name is all that original (although it may seem now to us that there could never be another Elvis): it's no "moonunit" (the name Frank Zappa gave to one of his unfortunate children). Indeed, analysis of the historical record suggests that the name was already in decline in the US when Elvis was christened. And as our own Dylan Thomas impersonator, Rory Sutherland, points out, Elvis is a Welsh name. It is the name of the bishop who baptised the future patron saint of God's Own Country, St David. This is why the original Church of St Elvis is not to be found in Memphis or Vegas, but on a windswept Pembrokeshire hillside, within reach of the city of St Davids and in sight of the Irish Sea.
"Before Elvis, there was nothing" John Lennon So what does all this Elvisology have to tell us about creativity and originality?
Well, first and most importantly, it's clear that copying and originality aren't polar opposites: being original and doing original work is often best achieved by using the power of copying. Elvis was a covers act, whose musical stylings were borrowed and honed through practice and accident. His iconic appearance was the result of borrowed fashions and styles. Even his name – perhaps the most "unusual" aspect of the piece – turns out to have a long, borrowed history. Elvis is not a fake but he is a copycat and that's what makes him and his music so original.
Other creative minds have long appreciated this simple truth about making original things: Sir Isaac Newton may possibly have been the most self-regarding of all physicists but even he was forced to admit that Descartes and Robert Hooke's work on the science of Optics had provided the basis of his own much acclaimed work.
Submit Your Work
Send us your work for the next issue of Directory using our submissions form
People Also Read
- From the pulpit
Issue 42, March 2017 - The GOOD Paper Project
Issue 50, March 2019 - Everything has an origin
Issue 61, December 2021